Connect
bruceleeroy's picture
Offline
LF ARMY #063
4857 Posts
5394 Points
Senior Red Jacket

I was wondering some people's thoughts on something. Last weekend here in Nashville there was a big rally about victims of rape. Probably stuff you've all heard before, things like "it's never the womans fault" and "people should be able to wear whatever they want" or "just because they are in a short skirt doesn't make them a slut".

OK, so 1st point. I 1000% agree it is NEVER the victims fault someone choose to pray on them.

However, I always think to myself that this does become a disservice to people from a self defense stand point. Yes, you 'should' be able to wear whatever you want. At the same time understand that if you are out by yourself at 4 am in a bad part of town with $10,000 earings and 8 inch heels. You look like a good target.

My oldest daughter just turned 13. I'm already telling her she should NEVER leave the group. Never leave drinks/food unattended (coke and stuff at the skating rink now, alchohol will come later). Know your surroundings, park under lights, carry your keys in between your fingers etc etc.

I'm listening to these people say "if you want to wear that, go ahead, it's your right." I feel like they are encouraging women to put themselves in more danger than they need to be. OK, yes, it's your right. But can we please use some common fricken sense. I weigh 250 lbs and train in MMA, I have every right to go walk in the worse neighborhoods in town with a big sign that says "I hate poor people". But I don't.

thoughts?

CombatChaz's picture
Online
LF GENERAL #000
23424 Posts
57650 Points
CombatChaz Jacket

People should be able to do/ wear what ever they want. However, some actions will just cause certain reactions period. Just like certain clothing worn by women will entice some men into inappropriate actions, it sucks, but that is life. it is just a reality.

thatguy0311's picture
Offline
214 Posts
288 Points
Green Jacket

I agree with bruceleeroy. You can wear whatever you want, but use some common sense, and not just where clothing is concerned. If you go to a seedy bar or something, and you aren't dressed or acting like a regular, you're going to get noticed. Calling attention to yourself is a surefire way to have something bad happen, especially when alcohol is involved. True, it isn't the rape victims fault-if they wanted it to happen then it wasn't rape, at the base level. But what steps did the victim take to prevent something like that from occuring? And if it did happen despite the victims best attempts, what's the plan of action when you're assualted? Everybody should have the right to go out and have a good time every so often, but common sense dictates to plan for the worst.

shawnsporter's picture
Offline
35 Posts
22 Points
White Jacket

See video

Chapelle is one of many comedians that joke about this, it's wrong but they're also dressing that way to get men's attention, straight men are wired through biology, it's not something we can help noticing.

CombatChaz's picture
Online
LF GENERAL #000
23424 Posts
57650 Points
CombatChaz Jacket

Quote:
http://youtu.be/2OBPaenkxdg
Chapelle is one of many comedians that joke about this, it's wrong but they're also dressing that way to get men's attention, straight men are wired through biology, it's not something we can help noticing.

For ShawnPorter:

SmashedYoFace's picture
Offline
149 Posts
117 Points
Senior Yellow Jacket

I agree with the above comments, however, I believe that the way a woman dresses does raise the chances but I don't think the way they dress necessarily causes rape. If a person has the mentality to rape someone I think they're going to find a victim regardless (skimpier clothes and nice jewelry has to heighten it) but it's probably based on location and timing more than anything. In the 1800's when woman dressed modestly rapes still occurred, and it pre-dates that as well. Woman should focus on keeping themselves safe by staying in groups, parking under lights like Bruce LeeRoy said. After midnight there's not a ton of fun safe things going on "freaks come out at night!"

LSBJJ's picture
Offline
LF ARMY #073
3945 Posts
4373 Points
LSBJJ Jacket

Here is a relative article on the subject that I read a couple days ago...

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB1000142405297020422620457660117424095232...

A Thin Line on Skirts

Note to women in the South Park Slope and surrounding Brooklyn: You might want to think twice before wearing shorts or skirts when you walk home alone at night.

That's the message some women say police officers are spreading as they step up patrols in the area in response to at least 10 unsolved sexual attacks that have taken place since March.

In a neighborhood with a reputation for liberal and feminist tendencies, the message is, as to be expected, not going over so well.

Lauren, a South Slope resident, was walking home three blocks from the gym on Monday when she was stopped.

The 25-year-old, who did not want her last name to be used, was wearing shorts and a T-shirt when she claims a police officer asked if she would stop and talk to him. He also stopped two other women wearing dresses.

According to Lauren, the officer asked if they knew what was going on in the neighborhood. When they answered in the affirmative, he asked if they knew what the guy was looking for.

"He pointed at my outfit and said, 'Don't you think your shorts are a little short?'" she recalled. "He pointed at their dresses and said they were showing a lot of skin."

He said that such clothing could make the suspect think he had "easy access," said Lauren.

She said the officer explained that "you're exactly the kind of girl this guy is targeting."

Asked whether officers were warning women against wearing shorts or skirts, the New York City Police Department responded in no time.

"Officers are not telling women what not to wear—there's a TV series that does that," quipped Deputy Commissioner Paul Browne in an email. "They are simply pointing out that as part of the pattern involving one or more men that the assailants have targeted women wearing skirts."

Note to the NYPD: It should be apparent by now that commenting on women's clothing is not a good idea, no matter how good the intention.

So it should come as no surprise that a grass-roots group formed in the wake of the attacks, Safe Slope, has criticized this alleged tactic—among other things—in an open letter posted on its website and Facebook page.

Jessica Silk, one of Safe Slope's founders, called such interaction with police "completely inappropriate."

"There have been reports that the women attacked were all wearing skirts," she said. "Unfortunately this might be a common link between the women that were attacked but the message shouldn't be that you shouldn't wear a skirt. The message should be that, 'Here are ways that you can protect yourself.'"

Lauren said she's been surprised by the male responses to the incident—including from her own father. She said the consensus among men is that while it was inappropriate for the officer to broach such a topic, they all think he has a point.

"I completely disagree," she said. "Where do you draw the line? I can't wear shorts? Besides the fact that I wasn't wearing anything that was inappropriate or provocative….I don't think that should be part of the problem. At all."

Lauren said she thanked the officer for patrolling the area but said she would prefer that he focus on apprehending the suspects, rather than the dressing choices of women.

To be fair, the police have clearly stepped up their presence in the South Slope, Greenwood Heights and Sunset Park area in recent weeks.

This week, police cars with their lights flashing were stationed at nearly every other block on Fourth Avenue outside of the Prospect Avenue subway station.

Some think the attention has become alarmist. Most of the assaults were attempts that included groping or grabbing, and didn't involve weapons. (There was one rape in Sunset Park, in May.)

Sketches of potential suspects are posted at local businesses, and on a recent day Jay "Rocket" Ruiz handed out Police Department "wanted" alerts for three men accused of attempted rape.

Mr. Ruiz (he said his name is a stage name) is a civilian who recently started the Brooklyn Bike Patrol, a volunteer group that escorts people who are afraid to walk home from 11 area subway stations. He said he's been getting more than a dozen calls on some nights. He said the local precinct screens all volunteers to ensure they don't have criminal records.

"I hate to see women getting attacked, that's one of the most cowardly acts anyone can do," said Mr. Ruiz. "We just want to get people home safe."

Wearing a fluorescent yellow T-shirt, Mr. Ruiz hollered, "Brooklyn Bike Patrol," "Free escorts home," and "Get home safe."

Meanwhile, Safe Slope started its own pilot program on Thursday night, making available volunteers to escort people home. And two local City Council members have funded free one-day self-defense workshops in the area.

The Center for Anti-Violence Education said it saw more than 80 women in three such workshops and two more are planned, including bilingual classes in Sunset Park, said Tracy Hobson, the center's executive director.

Many women who have taken the one-day course say they are considering enrolling in additional classes. "You know, it's gotten scary, quite honestly," said Shannon Sharpe, a 33-year-old who lives a block from where the first attack took place in March. "I just felt like I needed to be able to defend myself."

Ms. Sharpe says she's seen women at local bars call a car service to drive them as few as two blocks.

She, like other women, has had to change her routine due to safety concerns. She said she's stopped wearing high heels so often because it's harder to run in them. But she said she hasn't changed her clothing, because she doesn't normally wear mini-dresses or anything particularly sexy. "If I did, then maybe I'd be more conscious of that," she said.

"It's frustrating because there's probably something true to that," she said, referring to a certain type of clothing attracting sexual assailants.

Not everyone is scared.

Ronnie Yoked, a 29-year-old resident, stopped to talk to Mr. Ruiz this week as he handed out police alerts.

Ms. Yoked said she hopes she runs into the man—or men.

"I have my black belt in karate," she said. "They're all short dudes. I'm waiting for one of them to try to get me."

Let's hope the police get them first.

SmashedYoFace's picture
Offline
149 Posts
117 Points
Senior Yellow Jacket

My father was a Police Officer in Tacoma and we've spoke about this before. He told me stories of rapists they would catch that would sit and wait for the best option to not get caught (they caught a masked guy chillin on the rocks at the waterfront, probably waiting for a girl all alone to walk by). For example, if he's hiding and two girls walk by wearing skirts the guy may not go after them, but then if a girl in a parka walks by next by herself, the guy is probably going to attack her. Knowing if he targeted the woman because of the skirts is hard to tell... I look around my office right now (a law firm but we can all wear jeans) and a large majority of the woman are wearing skirts. When I go out to the bars, most woman are wearing skirts. It seems like a majority of woman in general wear skirts, so it can appear that it happened because of the skirt even thought that might not be the case. I think that jiu-jitsu should be taught as an after school protection program for the female students so at least they have some kind of comfort if they don't have anyone to help them or any kind of weapon to help protect themselves. Or maybe Tazer Thongs???

thatguy0311's picture
Offline
214 Posts
288 Points
Green Jacket
shawnsporter's picture
Offline
35 Posts
22 Points
White Jacket

thanks Chaz! Didin't even think about being able to embed the video...

CHOKETAPSNAP's picture
Offline
516 Posts
424 Points
Green Jacket

Don't wave a steak in a hungry bears face.

josh's picture
Offline
843 Posts
907 Points
Senior Green Jacket

I listened to some feminist on the radio organizing these protests.

Her basic idea was that a rapist is a rapist. And a rapist will rape a girl in jeans or a girl in a swim suit, it doesn't matter. So women should feel free to wear whatever because they have an equal chance of getting raped no matter what.

I disagree and I think everyone else does also. There are different degrees of rapists. Some will rape no matter what the woman is wear. Some might be pushed over the edge if they see a ton of cleavage.

bruceleeroy's picture
Offline
LF ARMY #063
4857 Posts
5394 Points
Senior Red Jacket

I'm not necessarily saying that seeing an extra inch of thigh is going to turn a non rapist into a rapist, or even that someone would pick a girl in a skirt over a girl in jeans. I guess my thing is drawing a ton of attention to yourself. I know you are going out to a club so the point is kind of to draw some attention.

I'll use another personal example. I go to a lot of football games. Since I don't live near my team I'm always wearing the 'wrong' stuff. Smile Now, some fan bases are known for starting more crap. When I'm by myself or with some guys it's not a big deal for me. But if my wife and kids are with me it's not worth the risk to draw that attention.

Natalie Holloway - not her fault she got murdered. But hey, all you other teens going to another country.....don't wander away from your friends with some dude you met a couple hours ago!

krazylarry's picture
Offline
743 Posts
957 Points
Senior Green Jacket

Am I the only one that feels rapist's should be executed? It won't solve the problem 100% but it will certainly help.

Been beaten and scarred, you'll never break me. I'm born again hard.

Jason Hill's picture
Offline
LF ARMY#057
1655 Posts
1765 Points
Blue Jacket

Everyone always ask me what I would do if I got jumped in an ally or in a bar fight. I tell them nothing I don’t go to bars and I don’t walk down alleys alone. I think people should be more aware of where they are and the people around them. The pizza company’s won’t deliver a pizza to my work after dark. Any one walking alone in the area after dark is not smart male or female. It is a high crime area the police know it and are working to fix it. But if you know a mugger or rapist are active in the area why risk it. Everyone should be responable for there own safety.


http://WWW.Karatemma.com

Created by MyFitnessPal.co

shawnsporter's picture
Offline
35 Posts
22 Points
White Jacket

Corporal punishment doesn't deter people very much, besides, it's way too expensive to execute people we already do! More so, the fact that your killing someone because of what they did is ridiculous, your basically letting that person off the hook, their not suffering anymore once their dead, yet the victim lives on.

It's sort of like spanking your kids. You can't spank them when you need to get the message across. But what kind of message does it really send to say
"you hit someone, I'm gonna hit you back because hitting is bad!"

powerof0ne's picture
Offline
1246 Posts
1212 Points
Blue Jacket

I'm all for execution for those that rape, but the problem is, if they're not clearly proven immediately of being guilty of doing so.  Unfortunately there are some cases of Women lying about being raped.  It's not as rare as many would think, neither.  

The legal system is a bit screwed up.  I don't trust a rapist, especially a serial rapist of ever being rehabilitated and being able to rejoin society as a contributing member, ever again.  I have a nifty app on my iPhone that shows all the registered and illegally unregistered sex offenders near me.  It's a bit sickening and suprising how many there are, and how close they are!

 

If someone is caught in the act, I believe they should be immediately shot and killed.  No trial, no arrest, just the cost of a bullet.  I know, this will enver happen in the USA but here's to hope...  

 

 

Keep training and enjoy what you do.

bruceleeroy's picture
Offline
LF ARMY #063
4857 Posts
5394 Points
Senior Red Jacket

Taking a look at those registered sex offender sites can be quite disturbing.  They are everywhere!

FireCat-75's picture
Offline
LF CAPT. #017
7861 Posts
7361 Points
Senior Red Jacket

I have mixed feelings on this

Courage does not always roar. Sometimes courage is the quiet voice at the end of the day saying "I will try again tomorrow"

FireCat-75's picture
Offline
LF CAPT. #017
7861 Posts
7361 Points
Senior Red Jacket

 I carry mace, and a very powerful teaser when I walk at night and I secretly pray that someone is that stupid.  J) I also walk with a 130lb dog that might be limiting my chances of an attack... and I don't really dress to impress so if someone did approch me I'd think they might be blind or just pathic

Courage does not always roar. Sometimes courage is the quiet voice at the end of the day saying "I will try again tomorrow"

myke7777's picture
Offline
1340 Posts
1442 Points
Blue Jacket

Women want 2 things.  Certainty and uncertainty.  Good luck.

It is what it is, with or without your reaction.

ptbeast's picture
Offline
959 Posts
1254 Points
Blue Jacket

Somehow, I missed this thread until now.  There is an underlying assumption here, that I think needs to be addressed.  Most rapes are comitted by people known to the victims: friends, relatives, dates, etc.  In these cases, sexual attraction may play apart, but it is hardly based on what a woman chooses to wear.  When it comes to stranger rape, it has been shown that it is generally not about sexual attraction, but about opportunity.  Predators seek out the weak.  While some rapists may have a "type" that they search for in their victims, there is little evidence that dressing provocatively puts women at higher risk for rape.

Situational awareness, staying in the company of friends, and keeping her wits about her is going to go much farther towards staying safe than censoring what they wear.

 

I am not saying that wearing revealing clothing and expensive jewelry when out on the town is the safest course of action.  It can make one more likely to be robbed or assaulted, but again, it is not what should be focused on in terms of prevention.  The things that make a person look like a victim are much more important.

Just two cents worth from a former police officer and a person who teaches people how not to become victims of crime...

Dave

 

 

Alive MMA/Brazilian Top Team
Portland, OR

ptbeast's picture
Offline
959 Posts
1254 Points
Blue Jacket

Mistakenly double posted.  Sorry.

 

Dave

Alive MMA/Brazilian Top Team
Portland, OR

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Smileys
:):D:bigsmile:;):p:O:|:(:~:((8):steve:J):glasses::party::love:
  • You may embed videos from the following providers bliptv, youtube. Just add the video URL to your textarea in the place where you would like the video to appear, i.e. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pw0jmvdh.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <p> <br> <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img> <embed> <object> <param>
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • You can use BBCode tags in the text.
  • Textual smileys will be replaced with graphical ones.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.