Connect

Slams in grappling comps?

Tank-Jitsu's picture
Offline
13804 Posts
14113 Points

TeamRenzo wrote:
Couldn't view the video...

Was it a BJJ comp? If so, I would not go anywhere near a BJJ comp that allowed slamming, I am surprised they got insurance to cover that.

it was a BJJ comp.



天下無難事,只怕有心人

Tank-Jitsu's picture
Offline
13804 Posts
14113 Points

DRay wrote:
Tank-Jitsu wrote:
imagine a 210+ going against a 150 guy and the 150 guy jumps guard...

If a 150 lb guy is foolish enough to jump guard on a 210+ guy... well, frankly he's in no position to complain about being slammed.

I'm all for weight classes, but that right there is a huge problem created by them.

maybe the 150 guy is like 6' so they have long limbs. it just might be their best way of winning, it would probably be difficult for that person to go for a takedown on the other guy. however, this is a very specific example. so most of the time, i would agree with you it would be foolish just to jump. it just depends on the situation i guess.



天下無難事,只怕有心人

Sicarii's picture
Offline
200 Posts
212 Points

THere are different types of tournaments, and different rulesets for different types. It is the responsibility of the competitor to know these rulesets AND to agree to them before competing. If you don't agree, don't compete. Personally, I don't like rulesets that allow me to get punched in the face... therefore, I don't compete in MMA.

As to slams specifically, I **PERSONALLY** don't do them for a number of reasons. First, I don't think it is very classy. Secondly, when I roll I want to be able to control my movements, and a slam is pretty uncontrolled. Third, I consider it a desperation move rather than a skillful technique; if I win, I want it to be on my technical merit. And finally (and my main reason), is because if I put my foot where I can lift a guy triangling me, I expose the leg hook. If he gets my leg, I'm screwed. I would prefer a more technical, and imo higher percentage, defense.

That said, in tournaments I roll with the expectation that my opponent is trying to hurt me. My first focus is to my own safety. If I neglect to look to my own safety first, I deserve the repercussions... especially if the rules clearly open the door for certain violent defenses.

josh's picture
Offline
843 Posts
907 Points

IMO Reilly & company summed up pretty well.

This thread reminds me of this:

[video]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NYN2EcoqcgQ[/video]

niteshroud's picture
Offline
405 Posts
349 Points

josh wrote:
IMO Reilly & company summed up pretty well.

This thread reminds me of this:

[video]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NYN2EcoqcgQ[/video]

k dawg lets WRESTLE

i couldnt stop laughing when i first saw this and this time it was just as funny

It's all a puzzle, isn't it, Joseph? Like a game of chess, perhaps. The pieces move, apparently aimlessly, but always towards one single objective: to kill the king. But who is the king in this game, Joseph? That is the question you must ask yourself.

josh's picture
Offline
843 Posts
907 Points

niteshroud wrote:
josh wrote:
IMO Reilly & company summed up pretty well.

This thread reminds me of this:

[video]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NYN2EcoqcgQ[/video]

k dawg lets WRESTLE

i couldnt stop laughing when i first saw this and this time it was just as funny

At first you really don't catch on to "buttflop" or "nutslap". Makes sense after a couple times though.

tat2edup's picture
Offline
6706 Posts
7700 Points

The bottom line here is that the slam was perfectly LEGAL. Weather or not you view it as technical, it was a legal technique and he used it to his advantage.
I dont agree with footstomps in MMA, I personally think its cheap, b/c the bones in the feet are so small and easy to break, possibly causing long term damage, however if I were to get foot stomped, I would be perfectly fine with it, b/c I knew before the fight that it was a legal strike.
If its legal Im gonna use it, and I expect my opponent to do the same.

Like it or not, slamming is a part of grappling. I dont think it is fair for a guy to be able to butt scoot all day, but Im not crying about it.

-Adam Mays "Courage is endurance for one moment more" "If size mattered, the elephant would be the king of the jungle." FREESTYLE AMERICAN SHOOT TEAM Thanks to eagles for the sig!

BigRed's picture
Offline
751 Posts
824 Points

Technically isn't a slam technical

its not to the same degree of technicality
but you need to understand how much you can lift, where to grab your opponent, i cant grab his arm and just expect to pick him up by it

i mean Judo is very technical with throw's
throw's are designed to cause the same thing as slams

i mean to best lift someone and slam them you know to grab low, use your hip flexors and drive upward, then to use your thighs to hold him, you know if you pop him on a shoulder its easier to support his weight rather then try to use all arm muscle

even slamming out of a triangle, you need to know how to stand up to stack your opponent, to get a grip on him, and then to pick him up and slam him down and which muscles to use

my training center

www.myspace.com/mtowncarrot

grasshopper's picture
Offline
179 Posts
187 Points

YES !!!! slams are king...... Reality is hell on the street in the cage or on the mat if it works use it didnt that fool know the counter to being picked up and slammed. I see alot of people on here crying about a slam but get real its a part of fighting and wrestling !!!!! If you cant take the heat get your arse off the mat!!!!!

www.hybridfightgear.com

Ladogaboy's picture
Offline
990 Posts
1001 Points

I have mixed feelings about slams in grappling competitions. I acknowledge that there is a greater chance of injury with slams than there are with throws and takedowns. And I acknowledge that it is a strength-based technique; however, I believe that it has its place.

Much like sambo, judo rules treat picking a person up for a slam as an escape (you cannot complete the slam; otherwise, you will be disqualified), and judo is where I am drawing my opinion of slams from. Judo does its best to mimic real-life situations. The philosophy is: if you were you to do what you do in competition out in the real world (or as the sport was being developed, the battlefield), what would be the results? That is where the scoring comes from.

A fast, powerful throw would result in your opponent's being debilitated (and possibly dead) were it to happen on a hard, unforgiving surface. In competition, that is an ippon... instant win.

Now, taking that a step further, think of how slams look in the eyes of a judoka. I'm out at a bar having a good time with my friends when a guy in a Tapout shirt starts messing me. We get in a tussle and he pulls guard and starts to apply a triangle. If I lift him six feet off the ground and slam him to the bar room floor, what would be the result?

Is it graceful? No. Is it highly technical? No. Is it an effective technique? Ask Arona... that is, if he remembers.

For me personally, I never want to lose sight of the purpose behind what I do. Yes, I train for discipline, I train to keep in shape, I train because the people I train with are like family. However, I also train because of the confidence that training brings out... confidence in that I know what my capabilities are and that I can take care of myself.

Just know that if I am in a situation where there is real danger to me or someone I care about, I wouldn't think twice about slamming the back of someone's head into the concrete. So consider that when you are perfecting your "techniques."

Stoli's picture
Offline
76 Posts
79 Points

I like leglocks, I hate slams. I would not put myself in the position to get slammed. If I felt I was open to get slammed I would let go.

flubber_guard's picture
Offline
782 Posts
751 Points

3 words.

Hook a leg.

"Do not sleep under a roof. Carry no money or food. Go alone to places frightening to the common brand of men. Become a criminal of purpose. Be put in jail, and extricate yourself by your own wisdom."
— Miyamoto Musashi (The Book of Five Rings)

kjhinn's picture
Offline
641 Posts
666 Points

the sambo rule sounds legit (raise em up but don't slam them down). It shows good control and impressive strength. No one here can't say they have broken guard or a hold on simple brute strength.

Granted it may or may not be fair; but the facts are nothing is fair.

Waaaaaaaaaaaay back in the day "fair" refered to the color of a person's skin (thats not racial; just a fact) as in "the fair haired lass" or wotnot.

In this case, it was a matter of "justice" because the rules allowed the slam.... a very cruel justice, but justice nonetheless.

Anyway; the rule could easily be applied as an escape (the sambo rule), and it could be applied as points or as an advantage... to the "slammer".

In that case then the person being slammed could still compete; and learn how not to get slammed... hook the leg I think once the guy stacks; right?

Tony

Sharks gotta swim or it dies.

BigRed's picture
Offline
751 Posts
824 Points

Ladogaboy wrote:

Is it graceful? No. Is it highly technical? No. Is it an effective technique? Ask Arona... that is, if he remembers.

seriously i almost wet myself laughing

my training center

www.myspace.com/mtowncarrot

tat2edup's picture
Offline
6706 Posts
7700 Points

The slam happend, it was legal, what is there to debate??? If you are afraid of slams, dont compete where they are legal, or learn to defend them, its that simple. Dont understand why this thread has carried on so far???
I agree that there are dangers, but the guy knew that there was a possiblility that he could get some frequent flier miles when he signed up. You cant blame someone for using every weapon available to them.
To some its a cheap, meathead move. To others its a powerful, shocking weapon. So we can all agree to disagree.

-Adam Mays "Courage is endurance for one moment more" "If size mattered, the elephant would be the king of the jungle." FREESTYLE AMERICAN SHOOT TEAM Thanks to eagles for the sig!

tat2edup's picture
Offline
6706 Posts
7700 Points

The slam happend, it was legal, what is there to debate??? If you are afraid of slams, dont compete where they are legal, or learn to defend them, its that simple. Dont understand why this thread has carried on so far???
I agree that there are dangers, but the guy knew that there was a possiblility that he could get some frequent flier miles when he signed up. You cant blame someone for using every weapon available to them.
To some its a cheap, meathead move. To others its a powerful, shocking weapon. So we can all agree to disagree.

-Adam Mays "Courage is endurance for one moment more" "If size mattered, the elephant would be the king of the jungle." FREESTYLE AMERICAN SHOOT TEAM Thanks to eagles for the sig!

Gerric's picture
Offline
224 Posts
206 Points

Somebody slams me in a grappling tournament, there probably gonna get KTFO.

InwardMastery's picture
Offline
34 Posts
37 Points

I don't get it. HS wrestlers slam each other all day, in practice and in matches. Getting slammed is just part of the sport, as is learning how to protect yourself when getting slammed.

A warrior lives by acting, not by thinking about acting, nor by thinking about what he will think when he has finished acting.
-Carlos Castaneda

4oz. in ya face's picture
Offline
169 Posts
191 Points

Gerric wrote:
Somebody slams me in a grappling tournament, there probably gonna get KTFO.

If I slam you in a grappling tournament, you'll already be KTFO'ed :lol: !


If you see me walking you better move aside,
'Cause many men haven't, and many men have died

Mess with the best, die like the rest! USMC

4oz. in ya face's picture
Offline
169 Posts
191 Points

InwardMastery wrote:
I don't get it. HS wrestlers slam each other all day, in practice and in matches. Getting slammed is just part of the sport, as is learning how to protect yourself when getting slammed.

+1 Slamming's a technique, not everyone knows how to do it right.......


If you see me walking you better move aside,
'Cause many men haven't, and many men have died

Mess with the best, die like the rest! USMC

tat2edup's picture
Offline
6706 Posts
7700 Points

Gerric wrote:
Somebody slams me in a grappling tournament, there probably gonna get KTFO.

Even if the slam was legal? You gonna knock them out for choking or armbarring you to?

-Adam Mays "Courage is endurance for one moment more" "If size mattered, the elephant would be the king of the jungle." FREESTYLE AMERICAN SHOOT TEAM Thanks to eagles for the sig!

tat2edup's picture
Offline
6706 Posts
7700 Points

4oz. in ya face wrote:
InwardMastery wrote:
I don't get it. HS wrestlers slam each other all day, in practice and in matches. Getting slammed is just part of the sport, as is learning how to protect yourself when getting slammed.

+1 Slamming's a technique, not everyone knows how to do it right.......

Exactly, this> :cry: is what this thread has become.

-Adam Mays "Courage is endurance for one moment more" "If size mattered, the elephant would be the king of the jungle." FREESTYLE AMERICAN SHOOT TEAM Thanks to eagles for the sig!

Ladogaboy's picture
Offline
990 Posts
1001 Points

tat2edup wrote:
4oz. in ya face wrote:
InwardMastery wrote:
I don't get it. HS wrestlers slam each other all day, in practice and in matches. Getting slammed is just part of the sport, as is learning how to protect yourself when getting slammed.

+1 Slamming's a technique, not everyone knows how to do it right.......

Exactly, this> :cry: is what this thread has become.

Meathead.

:lol:

:wink:

tat2edup's picture
Offline
6706 Posts
7700 Points

Ladogaboy wrote:
tat2edup wrote:
4oz. in ya face wrote:
InwardMastery wrote:
I don't get it. HS wrestlers slam each other all day, in practice and in matches. Getting slammed is just part of the sport, as is learning how to protect yourself when getting slammed.

+1 Slamming's a technique, not everyone knows how to do it right.......

Exactly, this> :cry: is what this thread has become.

Meathead.

:lol:

:wink:

ME NOT MEATHEAD, NOW ME ANGRY! (sticks needle in right buttocks)...:lol:

-Adam Mays "Courage is endurance for one moment more" "If size mattered, the elephant would be the king of the jungle." FREESTYLE AMERICAN SHOOT TEAM Thanks to eagles for the sig!

BigRed's picture
Offline
751 Posts
824 Points

i have this feeling someone is about to get slammed :lol:

my training center

www.myspace.com/mtowncarrot

Lion's picture
Offline
1864 Posts
2092 Points

:lol:

hard sparring session is like a cold shower in a warm day. It feels good.

http://roartrains.blogspot.com/

https://twitter.com/#!/Roartweets

mogmogboy88's picture
Offline
1 Posts
1 Points

slams shouldnt be allowed in grappling tournaments because it is a GRAPPLING tournament. im not even going to use the argument that slams require no skill to do.

slamming is a STRIKE. STRIKES are not allowed in GRAPPLING tournaments.

the only other takedowns/throws that is close to a slam is something like a standard hip toss but that can be done without SLAMMING the opponent

please dont bring up something like 'slams are allowed on the street' etc etc etc. its not a street fighting tournament. its a GRAPPLING tournament.

if you want something more realistic, we have MMA for that

if you allow slams you might as well allow kicks, knees, elbow,s punches, headbutts etc etc etc

Enrage's picture
Offline
343 Posts
343 Points

I think slams are fine when it's within the rules but the guy in this video took it to the next level.

Somewhere in the back of my mind when I'm fighting, wrestling with buddies whatever I'm thinking if this could actually seriously hurt the guy and using judgment. Once he got the guy past waist height on that slam it was beyond stupid and I'd be trying to back off on the move. Now I'd like to see that guy dropped on his head legal or not.

BigRed's picture
Offline
751 Posts
824 Points

mogmogboy88 wrote:
slams shouldnt be allowed in grappling tournaments because it is a GRAPPLING tournament. im not even going to use the argument that slams require no skill to do.

the only other takedowns/throws that is close to a slam is something like a standard hip toss but that can be done without SLAMMING the opponent

Quote:
Another reason to throw the opponent is to shock his body through smashing him forcefully onto the ground. If an opponent executes a powerful yet fully controlled throw, he can win a match outright (by ippon) on the basis that he has displayed sufficient superiority

^Judo rules
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Judo

you essentially learn to throw your opponent to disable him (knock him out)
also if its such a meathead move then how come everyone can do it, if you know how to use your muscles in your legs and back to pick up your opponent and slam them then is it a meathead move because you needed a technique to do so

high school wrestling involves lots of slams and its refereed to as grappling

oh and as for a hip toss, its not the only thing that slams, a soldi double leg, you can lift your opponents legs up to your head, and drop him on his upper back/neck (Couture vs Gonzaga, Couture vs Liddell)
or a suplex from behind can cause serious damage (Fedor vs Randleman)

there are so many examples of throws that drop you on your head other then just a hip toss

granted its grappling, but some tournies allow it
personally, if its gonna allow me to i would, your opponent should learn the technique to stop it

my training center

www.myspace.com/mtowncarrot

Gerric's picture
Offline
224 Posts
206 Points

4oz. in ya face wrote:
Gerric wrote:
Somebody slams me in a grappling tournament, there probably gonna get KTFO.

If I slam you in a grappling tournament, you'll already be KTFO'ed :lol: !
Highly unlikely but I'll take your word for it.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.