Strikeforce announcers draw my ire!
I know this post is a week late as most of you have moved on to UFC 118 in anticipation of a professional event, but the Stikeforce commentary team continues to defy my ability to tolerate inadequacy.
Let me begin with Frank Shamrock. I can appreciate the need for an member of the team educated in the finer points of MMA, and who better than a fighter w/ a name, right? Well, even if I could ignore staring at Shamrock's braces, I could not avoid cringing at his delivery.
Where Shamrock seems unpolished, Mauro Ranallo has succeeded in sounding too professional. His stylized metaphors sound rehearsed, as if he were giggling in his hotel room prior to the fight while picturing himself mentioning such a quip at the perfect time during the broadcast. However, the worst part is the overall quality of his voice, which translates to the viewer more as a TV/radio announcer playing MMA commentator than a knowledgable fan. Save that nonsense for Jimmy Lennon Jr. before the fight and during production packages.
I do not even know the the 3rd man's name (Gus ?), but he is basically the same as Ranallo, but with no recognition and no place in the ring with the fighters after the final bell. His interviews are like sterile procedures. He is completely extraneous.
The unfortunate effect of these oversights is that the commentary accompanying the fights seems like an afterthought.
Strikeforce needs a 2 man team, at least one of whom should be a fan of the sport that can speak intelligently on what is happening live. If an actual fighter is required, call up Pat Miletich from the minors.
And lose the suits guys. There are not any foregin dignitaries with comped seats in the front rows. For an arena of fans dressed in shirts that resemble body art, business formal wear is a ridiculous addition.
I'm not suggesting that a popular comic/TV host paired with a staright announcer is the solution. . . yes I am.
Grandmaster Red Belt in P(C)JJ
haha, that'd be sick! Bring in Bas!!d
-Jimmy

I think i could stand Ranallo if Bas were there.
Wasn't Steven Quadros in the mix for a bit, despite looking as if he might be prowling among the crowd for young maidens from which to drink?
Grandmaster Red Belt in P(C)JJ
I usually can stomach Mauro.. the "other guy" (Gus?) sounds like he's auditioning for ABC Sports or The Weather Channel.. and Quatros reminds me of the Cryptkeeper. Like his skin is stretched too tight over his skull or something.
^ lol!
-Jimmy

i was watching friday night fights a week or so ago and i realized that i preferred the joe tessitore/teddy atlas combo to pretty much any combo in mma. it's not often that you can say the broadcasting made the experience more enlightening AND enjoyable.
i think there's something to be said about the knowledgeable professional with a great voice on play by play and the grizzled, colorful veteran on color.
--nick

10th dan in parnes jiu-jitsu.
Post new comment
User login
Latest Comments
- LimaLima
- DAC54
- CombatChaz
- FireCat-75
- Filessika
- OldSklHkr
- ptbeast
- CombatChaz
- kievpapa
- CombatChaz
- FireCat-75
- Chojin
- CombatChaz
- ransom
- FireCat-75
- FireCat-75
- FireCat-75
- New Jersey Martial Arts
- CombatChaz
- OldSklHkr
- prettyboygerard
- tofu
- CombatChaz
- El Bow
- CombatChaz
Upcoming events
- Reilly Bodycomb Sambo and Leg Lock Seminar Houston, TX Febrary 18th(7 days)
- North American Throwdown! www.caccmedia.com (14 days)
- ASA & ISWA Freestyle Sambo and Catch Wrestling Tournament(14 days)
- Arlington Submission Challenge 11(21 days)
- THE GOOD FIGHT: Tournament of Brotherly Love IV(35 days)
- THE GOOD FIGHT: 2012 Virginia Open(77 days)
- THE GOOD FIGHT: 2012 Boston Open(84 days)























Bas Rutten FTW!!!
-Adam Mays "Courage is endurance for one moment more" "If size mattered, the elephant would be the king of the jungle."
FREESTYLE AMERICAN SHOOT TEAM Thanks to eagles for the sig!